Musical (director) chairs: Why the recent shakeups at Lucasfilm aren’t necessarily a bad thing

gallery-1487697013-han-solo-cast-photo-1So far, I’ve been very pleased with the way Disney has handled the Star Wars universe since they purchased Lucasfilm back in 2012. I loved “Episode VII: The Force Awakens” and “Rogue One: A Star Wars Story.” I’m still a little bummed Disney made the old Star Wars Expanded Universe novels go away, but the new canon novels are getting better (the “Rogue One” novelization is excellent, by the way).

However, there have been a few road bumps in Star Wars land this year. Phil Lord and Christopher Miller — directors of the upcoming Han Solo prequel film, perhaps best known for their work on “The Lego Movie” — were fired in June over alleged creative differences regarding the project, and Ron Howard was asked to step in. Most recently, Colin Trevorrow was ousted as the director of Episode IX. “The Force Awakens” director J.J. Abrams will take over.

It’s easy to feel concern over something as major to a project as a director shakeup, and wonder if the studio is being too controlling or lacking a cohesive vision. Especially when, in the case of the Han Solo movie, months of filming had already taken place when the directors were fired. However, based on Disney’s handling of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the previous Star Wars films, I’m going to side with them on this one. Of course I’ll have to wait until I see the finished product, but I think they likely made the right call.

I loved Lord and Miller’s Lego movie — it was one of the funniest and most creative movies I’d seen in a long time. But an overly comedic tone is not really what I want from a Star Wars movie. According to rumors, the directing duo was trying to make the Han Solo movie into a comedy with supposedly too much improvisation. Although I do think it’s good for directors have some room to bring a fresh vision to these well-established franchises, you don’t want to veer too far off course from that classic “Star Wars feel.” Gareth Edwards did a great job bringing a gritty war movie tone to “Rogue One” while still having it feel like a Star Wars movie. The Wikipedia page for the Han Solo movie calls it a “space western” and I really hope that’s the tone Ron Howard is able to draw out.

I also feel it was ultimately a good decision to part ways with Colin Trevorrow, at least for now. His “Jurassic World” was a fun movie but not a flawless one; nostalgia, dinosaurs, and Chris Pratt carried the film more than the plot. Trevorrow’s recent “The Book of Henry” was not well received by critics, and I have a feeling his removal from the Episode IX project had at least something to do with this.


Not everyone has been thrilled J.J. Abrams is returning to the Star Wars universe, but I’m personally really excited. Abrams is actually one of my favorite directors. I think he approaches filmmaking with a lovely sense of childlike wonder, and I believe he will bring an epic closure to the Star Wars sequel trilogy. I liked all the elements of nostalgia in “The Force Awakens”; after the prequel trilogy, a lot of fans felt burned, and it was probably best to take a safer approach with Episode VII. I think Episode VIII will push into some newer, darker territory, and Abrams will (hopefully!) be able to blend all that together in the final film.

As I was chatting with my husband about the Star Wars director shakeups, I did have to admit that Abrams and Howard are fairly “safe” choices for the franchise, and Disney doesn’t seem keen to take a whole lot of risks at this point. At least for now I want the Star Wars movies — at least the main ones — to keep having that similar, classic feel. However, in the future I think Disney should feel confident enough to take a few risks with the anthology films, venturing out beyond the template they’re comfortable with. We may never see a gritty, R-rated Star Wars bounty hunter/gangster movie set in the seedy underbelly of Coruscant or the back alleys of Mos Eisley, but wouldn’t that be awesome?


7 thoughts on “Musical (director) chairs: Why the recent shakeups at Lucasfilm aren’t necessarily a bad thing

  1. Great Post!
    I still haven’t summoned any enthusiasm for a Han Solo movie, nor am I excited about a Kenobi movie which they announced last week.
    And NO, pls let’s not have a Boba Fett movie! That we have no background knowledge of him adds to his mystique, and thus, his appeal.
    Personally, I want to see more of Bossk and 4-LOM – they looked so good in Th Empire Strikes Back, and yet they didn’t have anything to do!
    A gritty, R-rated Star Wars bounty hunter/gangster movie? Blimey, that sounds groovy!
    Never say never, Ash! 😉

    • I’m not super thrilled with a young Han Solo movie, especially since Harrison Ford’s performance was so iconic (he IS Han Solo). Although I am excited to see Woody Harrelson in a Star Wars movie and I think Donald Glover is an awesome choice to play young Lando. And I have to admit I’ve been wanting a spin-off Obi-Wan movie for a long time. 😉 I thought Ewan McGregor was the best part of the prequel films, and I’d love to see him return to the character in a quasi-Western set on Tatooine.

      I’d really like to see that gritty, R-rated Star Wars bounty hunter/gangster movie, so I’m trying to get a rumor started in hopes that someday Disney will consider it. 😉 ha ha

      Thanks as always for stopping by!

      • Woody Harrelson in a Star Wars movie?
        I still can’t get my head round that, but then again, never in a million parsecs cld I envisage Donnie Yen mixed up in th franchise, but see how cool he turned out to be!
        I hope u get th Obi-Wan movie u wish for

  2. Excellent post. I’ve been thinking a little about this as well and you’ve mentioned a lot of points I also had on my mind. If I read in between the lines from what the studio and Rogue One director said, I think Gareth Edwards wasn’t as hands on in the reshoots and editing process, he called it a team effort. So far Disney is playing it pretty safe, I can understand why, but let’s see if upcoming movies will take some risks.

    • Thank you! 🙂 I definitely think Disney is moving ahead very carefully, and I think that’s a good approach for now. However, in the future I do hope they take some more creative risks and push the franchise a little more outside its comfort zone. Will be interesting to see what happens, especially after Episode IX wraps up!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s