Superhero showdown: DC’s ‘Dawn of Justice’ vs. Marvel’s ‘Civil War’

civilwar2If you’ve read my blog, you’ve probably figured out by now that I’m a huge Marvel fan, probably second only to my love for Star Wars. 😉 So it likely comes as no surprise that I geeked out — big time — over the recently released second trailer for “Captain America: Civil War” (we finally get to see the new Spider-Man!). The film comes to theaters May 6, and it already looks amazing. I’m trying not to let myself get too hyped up ahead of time, because I felt the same way about the trailer for “Avengers: Age of Ultron,” a film that ultimately didn’t quite live up to the expectations fans had for it. However, I think “Civil War” will end up delivering the darker conflict and character development we were hoping for from “Age of Ultron.” We’ll get to see what happens when the Avengers are forced to fight against each other in a conflict with more gray areas than black and white.

“Civil War” isn’t the only superhero vs. superhero film this year — “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice” premieres March 25. I admit I do have a Marvel bias, so that’s probably one of the reasons why I’m not *quite* as excited for “Dawn of Justice” as I am for “Civil War.” 😉 It also will be difficult for DC to top Christopher Nolan’s previously released Batman trilogy, which ranks among the best superhero movies ever made. Will one of these two superhero vs. superhero movies emerge as the victor at the box office, or do they both have a chance to shine?

“Captain America: Civil War” will likely be the highest-grossing film of the summer, barring another “Jurassic World”-type surprise (and it may even be the highest grossing film of the year, though I’m still pulling for “Star Wars: Rogue One”). I’m really excited to see this film, which I hope will be genuinely game-changing for the Marvel Cinematic Universe, in a way that “Age of Ultron” could have been but wasn’t. Iron Man and Captain America are my two favorite Avengers, and I’ve always enjoyed watching the dynamic between them. Although the dilemma raised by the film is a completely hypothetical one, it’s also incredibly intriguing: should people with super powers be held accountable for their actions, and if so, who should hold them accountable? And do the people holding the superheroes accountable need to be held accountable, as well? Another feature which makes this conflict interesting is that Tony Stark, who’s normally a bit of a rebel, is in favor of more government oversight of superheroes, while the formerly loyal soldier and ultimate S.H.I.E.L.D. agent Steve Rogers find himself suspicious of that authority.

I’m also super excited to see the introduction of Black Panther, and I’m glad Spider-Man and Ant-Man will have roles in this film. The only potential downside I see is that the film could end up packed with too many heroes, and we’ll lose sight of the central conflict between Iron Man and Captain America. This is going to be a big, epic film, but it also needs some powerful personal moments, as well.

I’m a little more concerned about “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice,” but I’d like to see it succeed too. This film also has an opportunity to show how superheroes hold each other accountable, and then set aside their differences to combat a larger threat. Unlike Marvel, which spent several years releasing solo superhero films and then gave us an epic round-up, DC is introducing a lot of heroes at once and then will give us individual films later. While this strategy could backfire, because we don’t have the same attachment to some of these new characters as we do to Thor or Captain America, thanks to their solo films, it could help get people excited about these new characters and motivate fans to see the solo films when they do come out.

Some have expressed skepticism about Ben Affleck as Batman, but I think he could surprise us. I like how the film is presenting an older, more world-weary Batman. This isn’t an origin story; Batman has been a vigilante for a long time now, and maybe he’s struggling under the weight of it all. I think “going darker” is a good strategy for this film; Marvel movies are known for being fun — and funny, but a grittier tone could help “Dawn of Justice” stand out. I hope Wonder Woman will have a significant role in this film, and I’m looking forward to her solo film in 2017. Right now I’m not sure if I’m buying Jesse Eisenberg’s take on Lex Luthor, but I’m hoping that will surprise me too.

So, what do you think? Which superhero showdown film will top the box office? Which one are you most looking forward to?


9 thoughts on “Superhero showdown: DC’s ‘Dawn of Justice’ vs. Marvel’s ‘Civil War’

  1. Have you read the Marvel Civil War story arc? If you haven’t, I would highly recommend you check it out before the film comes out. I’m sure the trade paper back is easy to find. It will not be a straight adaptation but it looks like the central themes are still there.

    I’m ‘meh’ towards Dawn of Justice but that’s from my dislike for Superman. I’ll probably still see it because A) Batman and B) it’s the real start of the DCCU.

    • I haven’t read the original comic story yet; it’s now on my list to check out at my local library! Although I really like Batman, I’ve found the other DC heroes just don’t draw me in as much as the Marvel heroes do. But I’m also curious to see how the DC Cinematic Universe kicks off, and I hope it works. It will be interesting to see what fans and critics have to say!

    • I am simply not a big fan of Snyder as a director. The only thing which gives me hope for this movie is the fact that he has a different script writer this time around. But I have a bad feeling that Batman vs Superman will be another Man of Steel, not bad enough to tank this franchise, but also not good enough to get the approval of the fans who want more than fight scenes and pseudo-philosophical BS.

      Civil War is the follow up to one of my favourite MCU movies, part of my favourite MCU franchise (along with GotG) and done by largely the same team…naturally I am excited!!!! I can’t wait!

      • Agreed–Batman v Superman is not necessarily a sure hit, and I felt DC hasn’t really “earned” a team-up film in the same way that Marvel did. Captain America: The Winter Soldier is also one of my favorite Marvel movies, and it looks like Civil War will build on this film and take the story to a new level. I’m pumped!

  2. Yeah!
    Great Trailer 2 for th Cap
    Personally, I’m a bit fed up w Spider-Man (avoided th whole will he/won’t-he-appear-in-this fuss), but am interested in seeing T’Challa/Black Panther cos we’ve never seen him on th big screen before.
    Nah – I can wait until Yawn of Justice comes out on disc, but am curious to know how they will handle th debuts of Wonder Woman & Aquaman.
    Not keen on Eisenberg’s Luthor either.

    • I’ve very curious about the stand-alone Wonder Woman movie coming next year. I’m excited for a solo film for a female superhero, though I am still hoping for a Black Widow movie (but don’t think we’ll actually get one).

  3. I’ll be watching both Civil War and BvS in theaters, I’m looking forward to both. But I think Civil War will be the more complete movie. And the trailers for Civil War are more promising than what I’ve seen of BvS. I do like Affleck’s Batman so far, his clips in the trailer are the best parts. How it will all come together in the final movie I’m a bit more cautiously hopefully. 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s