Review: ‘Battleship’ a ‘hit’ or a ‘miss’?

The movie “Battleship” has taken quite a bit of flak in the months leading up to its release based on the fact it’s a film inspired by a board game. There’s been jokes about what phrases from the game might end up as dialogue in the film (such as, “You sunk my battleship!”) and about what other board game-to-film projects we’ll be seeing in the future (coming next summer to a theater near you, a film about a family of explorers who find themselves trapped in a deadly jungle and facing down the most frightening terror they’ve ever experienced: a pack of hungry, hungry hippos …).

So, despite some of the initial skepticism from filmgoers and critics, is the final movie based on Hasbro’s classic naval combat game a “hit” or a “miss”? It has the same kind of feel as Michael Bay’s “Transformers” films, except with a naval twist — and whether that’s a good thing or not depends a lot on how you feel about the “Transformers” movies.

The film follows Lieutenant Alex Hopper (Taylor Kitsch), who is pressured by his older brother Commander Stone Hopper (Alexander Skarsgård) to join the Navy and do something constructive with his life. Alex has a difficult time staying out of trouble, and after getting into a fight on the day of an international naval exercise off the coast of Hawaii, he is informed by Admiral Shane (whose daughter he is dating) he likely will find himself kicked out of the Navy when they return from the exercise.

Fate intervenes, and an alien invasion forces Alex to take command of a U.S. Navy destroyer. Alex and his team must figure out how to destroy the alien forces and prevent them from sending a message back to their home planet. Alex’s ship is trapped inside a force field created by the aliens, preventing him from receiving any backup from other naval vessels outside the field.

The film has received a mixed reaction from audiences and critics. Rotten Tomatoes reviewer David Nusair calls it “epically bad in virtually every way imaginable,” while Scott Nash says, “I never thought I’d be saying this about this movie, but I enjoyed it. … It was … kind of fun in a big, loud, brainless summer blockbuster kind of way. It’s certainly better than the ‘Transformers’ movies.”

I must confess (don’t judge me!) that I did enjoy the film. I liked watching the battles at sea, and I thought the Navy ships were utilized well in the film. I also liked that film makers included a character who was a disabled military veteran. Lieutenant Colonel Mick Canales (played by real-life veteran and amputee Gregory D. Gadson) lost both his legs and is having a hard time coping with his injury, both physically and emotionally. However, he regains his will to fight, and he gets to play a key role in stopping the alien invasion. I thought it was a nice way to recognize the service of soldiers and the struggle they have after returning from combat. Sometimes society doesn’t always pay as much attention to veterans, especially disabled veterans, as it should.

The film did have some weaknesses, though. At times, the references to the original game are a bit too obvious, and I think (spoiler alert!) Alexander Skarsgård’s character was killed off too soon. I also wish Liam Neeson would have been given more screen time as Admiral Shane (end spoiler!).

“Battleship” may not be a deep or thought-provoking film, but like “Transformers,” it’s a CGI roller coaster ride. Granted, it’s not a rousing epic like some of the best recent summer blockbusters (J.J. Abrams’ 2009 “Star Trek” reboot, last summer’s “X-Men: First Class”); however, it’s still fun, and I found it to be an entertaining way to spend an afternoon.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Review: ‘Battleship’ a ‘hit’ or a ‘miss’?

  1. good review! And don’t worry I liked it too. Battleship is a film that knows its a silly action film and doesn’t try to be anything else. It also turns out to be enjoyable because of it.

    The references to the board game I thought was the best/funniest thing about it. You are right about neeson as well. It’s a shame we didn’t get to see him explore his serious naval officer character in more detail. It would of been great to see him smash some aliens heads together while coming out with a bad ass one-liner. Oh well bring on Taken 2 I suppose.

    In the meantime Keep up the good work! I enjoy reading your reviews 🙂

    • Thanks! And I’m glad to hear I’m not the only one who liked it. You’re absolutely right, it’s just a fun, light-hearted action film that doesn’t take itself too seriously. I would have liked to see Liam Neeson fight against the aliens as well, though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s